The Melting Pot
Amalgamation of Thoughts…

The right way ?

September 28th 2009 in Random

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

The Mahabharat and The Ramayan are India’s two greatest epics. Both are celebrated as the victory of good over evil. The good versus evil story is as old as civilization itself. But, what sets these two epics apart is the absence of absolute and outright evil figures. In both these epics, the antagonists suffer from the vices that are found in each and every person – jealousy, arrogance, greed, lust, vanity etc. The antagonists Ravan and Duryodhan are more tragic than despicable.

In the Ramayan, Ravan is a highly learned and fearless Brahmin. He is a just and generous king for his people. Ravan had every right to wage war against Ram for Lakshman’s humiliation of his sister Srupanakha after she proposed to Ram. However, Ravan’s deceitful abduction of Ram’s wife Sita and attempted seduction was a cowardly and despicable act, an act of adharma. The figures of Meghnath, his son and Kumbhkaran,his brother are the most fascinating. Kumbhkaran was believed to be a noble warrior who chided Ravan for his cowardly action of abducting Sita but ultimately sided with Ravan out of loyalty. Similar is the case of Meghnath, a fierce warrior who chose loyalty over everything else. While, both of them chose loyalty and sided with adharma, they are respected and venerated for the same. While Vibhishan, who forsake loyalty and sided with Ram and dharma is synonymous with treachery.Vibhishan’s name died with him but Indrajit’s name has lived till now.

The Mahabharat too deals with the conflict within man. The principal antagonist Duryodhan is jealous of his cousins. He cheats them out of their kingdom and humiliates them and their wife. There is no doubt that he’s in the wrong but still figures like Dronacharya, Bhishmapitama, Kripacharya and Karna support Duryadhan out of loyalty to him either as a King or as a friend.

So, the question I ask myself is what is a man to do ? If he forsakes loyalty and sides with dharma, he is damned like Vibhishan. If he chooses loyalty over dharma, he faces the same fate as Karna and Bhishma. Which is the right path ?



Your Ad Here

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

8 comments to...
“The right way ?”
    Avatar
    Prabhjot Kaur

    Totally True….
    I am very fascinated by the chracters of Ramayana..
    All of them were powerful but exhibited human-like tendencies..
    Thats is wht connects every person to these epics in some way for the other..


    Reply
    Avatar
    Rahul Sarin

    The right path is the path you believe in, in my opinion. The path you choose may depend upon your situation, the environment, the circumstances and a variety of other factors. What may seem good to us, might be actually foolish in that situation. As they say, "Jis tan laage, us tan jaane"… Every human has a basic sense of ethics and morality in him. It depends upon us how we perceive those ethics and rules and how we implement them in our decisions. These are situations in which either way you end up doing something wrong. We judge what is best based upon our own priorities.


    Reply
    Avatar
    Praveen

    There is no definite answer. But when you go to Mahabharata Krishna gives Arjuna advise to take smart decisions in the wake of regaining their lost glory. Attempting to destroy the enemies with treachery is not a crime according to Lord Krishna. If Arjuna would not kill the Kauravas, fate would act upon and kill the kauravas eventually by Karma.

    So one is an instrument of God's play.

    .


    Reply
    Avatar
    Divya Bhanot

    It certainly depends on situation what 2 choose. Ramayana and Mahabharata shows victory of good over evil. But it does show something else if you try to picture things little differently. Demons or Villains are meant to be evil , by being themselves they teaches us not to be like them . So ,they do something which even good can't do. There's something i would like to share , on the eve of Dussehera before burning the effigy of Ravana ,he is worshiped not because he was a pundit but because he taught us what he did in his fabricated ego is not to be done . Good and Bad are "Purak" of each other like night and day.


    Reply
    Avatar
    Sophia

    There is not any formula or mechanism to find the right path. We've to decide the path ourselves and while chosing the path we know that if it is a right path or a wrong one.

    Like in Mahabharat – "Bhishm Pitamah" knew that Pandava's were right. But his dharma was to protect and be with Duryodhan (so we cant say he was at "Adharm ka path" as according him it was his dharma). And in Ramayana – Kumbhkaran and Meghnath knew that Ravana is wrong at his place, but they chose to support him. We all know what path is correct or not but we end up choosing the best, considering the circumstances n situations of that time.

    And according to Indian Mythology – the Evil comes in action, just to keep the belief of victory of "Good over Evil." and that is why Dusshera is celebrated to remind the victory of Goodness.

    Really very nice thought of the author and very nice comments.


    Reply
    Avatar
    @rkartha

    Your perspective of the characters of the Epics are interesting. As rightly pointed out by Rahul Sarin, it depends on the perspective of a person how he approaches a situation. In general, Ravan & Duryodhan have been largely portrayed as evil characters completely ignoring the goodness & virtue in them.

    I wonder if it would be appropriate to say that Raavan was a Brahmin. As I understand, Ravan's father was a Brahmin & Mother a Demon. You can refer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ravana for details.

    Why do you think that Vibhishan was damned & why do you equate Dharma with Treachery? In my opinion comparing Dharma with Treachery does not make sense. Kumbhakaran or Indrajit are not known for their loyalty either. It was for their respective traits of expertise in warfare.

    Right & Wrong is a completely relative and depends on your perspective, commitments & the situation. What is Right for you may not be Right for someone else & vice versa.

    I am not a frequent blog reader. So, if you have any comments please catch me on Twitter.


    Reply
    Avatar
    Varun Vasisht

    The reason I say Vibhishan is damned because even to this day he is popularly associated with 'Ghar ka bhedi,Lanka dhaaye' .How many Vibhishans do we see around us ? There are plenty of Inderjeets .This is to my understanding a negative portrayal. I agree that Indrajit and Kumbhkaran are known for their skills as warriors but still Kumbhkaran is a rather comical figure . For me , they represent the sailors of a sinking ship who chose to stay . Now,if they are evil for siding with Ravana , then so are Bhishma,Karan and Drona . I don't believe that there was ever a dilemma in their minds about Right or Wrong . They chose their side . As for Ravan,he was a learned scholar of the Vedas and other scriptures and thus I term him a 'Brahmin' ; it has nothing to do with who his father was (which is the essence of casteism) .


    Reply
    Avatar
    @BombayDrifter

    I would like to draw my lessons from the Mahābhārata, especially from Karṇa and Bhishm Pitamah. The defining trait in both their lives is their loyalty, or even fealty, in the case of the latter. In all this talk of dhárma and adhárma, the values of the Śrī Bhagavad Gītā are forgotten, which say that the definition of what is one's dhárma varies from person to person. It may sound archaic, but a person's dhárma varies according to the station one holds in life. True valour and righteousness mean walking the path of one's own dhárma, irrespective of what the world thinks. Characters like Karṇa and Bhishm Pitamah were flawed, no two ways about it; but through their loyalty towards their causes, in Karṇa's case, Duryodhan, and Bhishm Pitamah's fealty to the throne of Hastinapur, they endowed a sense of divinity onto their own humanity.


    Reply

Leave a Reply



required



required - won't be displayed


Your Comment:

 

About the Author

This article has been written by :

Varun

BIO :

VarunHas written 38 atricles

This is the real life story of a man who dared to believe until he realized he had ‘friends’ -

You see a girl in college and there’s instant infatuation. You can’t explain why you like her but you do. The next thing you do is you try to know more about her through your friends. [...]

Previous Entry

Taj – The symbol of love, an Indian legacy to cherish about, a monument that can enchant your soul. The city that contains not only Taj but three great World Heritage sites – Agra fort, Fatehpur Sikri and Taj, has its roots in our own country friends!!! Cheers!!! Is it???
No!!! In fact, it’s an absolute shame for the country.
Despite getting independence [...]

Next Entry


Your Ad Here